Deleting and re-entering form 2441 worked! There may be a glitch in Form 2441 on Turbotax when it is opened before both W-2s are entered (perhaps thinking you can't get the credit if both W-2s aren't there?). And it won't self-correct once the second W-2 is entered. Try making sure BOTH W-2s are entered, delete any previously started form 2441, and re-enter form 2441 questions. Totally fixed the problem!
