Ok, I found it! Now I see everything showing up as you said it should.
I am on the OSX CD/Download version, so the search function didn't work properly. To get to the screen you mentioned, I had to go to "Deductions and Credits" tab -> "Retirement and Investments". I was mistakenly trying to find it on "Wages & Income" tab -> "Retirement Plans and Social Security."
Thanks again for all your help!
