That was a waste of time. I started my taxes over, and followed the "ask-me-everything" mode only to have it tell me again that $302 of my wife's contribution is taxable. But now, there's even less of an indication why it thinks it's taxable.
I am 100% sure that there is a bug. Since my wife and I did essentially the same transaction and got the same documentation from the broker... either both of the transactions would be taxable... or neither of them would be. And since we both recharacterized a 2019 Roth contribution, we've already paid the taxes on that money. What's more, after entering the information, I got a screen saying "The good news is that you don't owe any additional taxes"... for both sets of 1099-R's.
I'm trying to find an email, phone number, or some way to contact Turbo Tax customer support to report this as a bug. But I can't find anything except this TurboTax community page.
