khsharara
Returning Member

RSUs sold to cover taxes show a gain sent to the government, why am I being taxed on this gain?

  • On Jan 1, I had
    • 100 RSUs vest with a cost basis of $1 each
      • 70 RSUs were deposited in my account and are never sold
      • 30 were held by the broker to cover taxes
  • On Jan 5
    • The stock value increased from $1 to $1.10 and the broker sold the 30 RSUs at $33 to cover taxes. This $33 dollars went straight to the government
  • During tax season
    • Broker sends 1099-B that reports a short term taxable gain of $3 for the 30 RSUs they sold to cover taxes

 

Question: If the government already collected $30 basis + $3 gain on Jan 5, why am I being taxed on the $3 gain that was already sent to the government? Am I missing something?