"Is this the correct way to report it?"
No. Use the installment sales method for the sale. The "proceeds" will include the amounts in escrow.
"The total for each of these shows as 0. Is this correct?"
That's an impossible question to answer definitely. However if the sale is a disqualifying sale and the price per share the public company paid is the same price used to calculate the compensation reported on the W-2 then "$0" would be correct.
Question to you: Is the compensation reported on the W-2 based on ALL shares sold, even though payments are expected in 2019 and 2020?
