Investors & landlords

There's no need for me to do any more because the broker obviously has made ALL the calculations for you and even split the transaction into its two component parts, one for the Sec 351 calculation and the other for the Redemption calculation.

The reason I came up with different answers based on your summary information is because the "Cost Basis" figures you disclosed were not your actual cost figures for the shares; they are the cost figures the broker "derived" in order to come up with the correct gain to report on your 1099-B.