1098t -hr block and turbo tax each give HUGE difference

claiming my 19yo unemployed student as a dependant, i already received help from this forum as to the loophole and the american credit to maximize MY return

 

however, each year i put all my info into both hr block and turbo to see if the numbers are about the same

 

usually they are. this year hr block says i am not qualified to take the american credit. my return is just over $200

turbo says hell yeah, you qualify and my return is just over $2700

 

and i am very confused and nervous about submitting it

i put all the info in exactly the same!