Deductions & credits

That is what is so weird. I entered the date of the donation, selected household items, typed "Various toys" into the description, the value of everything added up from that day was $3,245, and chose replacement cost new, because that is how much it would cost, without tax, if we were to purchase all those toys again new. When I selected "Done with this donation" that is when it started to ask about the purchase info, if I owned it for more than a year, and how the charity was going to use it since it had appreciated. In years past, I had not run into this and I am wondering if it is because if grouping it into a larger amount triggered something? I saw if you make a large donation, you have to fill out a form that requires you to itemize what was donated, so maybe I should go back to my old way and list off everything? Or is putting the replacement cost new the wrong choice and a different dollar amount should be listed instead?

Example: Paw Patrol Jungle Rescue Vehicle is 49.99 on Amazon. Do I use 49.99 since we donated the full toy with accessories? or a percentage since it was a donation?