State tax filing

This is not working.  $150 was withheld in Michigan (4.25%) for work in Michigan.  $480 was withheld in Illinois(4.95%) for work in Illinois.  My initial results were an additional $210 to be paid to Michigan and an $84 refund from Illinois.  Shouldn't I be getting a $480 refund from Illinois and paying some additional amount to Michigan?   Instead of current withholding of $630, I'm out $756.  I need the refund from Illinois to pay Michigan but the  "Other State Tax Credit" does not allow an entry for Illinois, even though it is a reciprocity state.