I'm not sure if I'm setting this up correctly. So I went back to the NY nonresident form and just entered in the income tax information like normal, but instead of refunding my entire NY income tax amount, it's still saying I owe money. However, for CA form, it's giving me a credit back for the full amount that I would've owed CA. My income taxes in CA should be lower than the income taxes I paid NY so I technically should be getting money back here. I'm not sure if I'm just still not entering in the NY information correctly.
