I am in neither group; my charitable deductions were not allocated based on income (which would be wrong in my case), nor were they allocated at all. The deductions wound up fully assigned to *both* states, i.e., I am getting all charitable deductions twice. TurboTax properly asked for income and 1099 and some other data to be allocated, and the proper allocations were made, but TurboTax never asked for an allocation of charitable deductions. Perhaps only someone who has actually solved this problem can help.
