@Chico D. Mann Thank you for the update and clarification for others. I had been thinking of recommending that you paper file the return and include a copy of the nonresident local return showing the tax paid. Problem is Philadelphia doesn't require you to file such a return when the tax was properly withheld by your employer, so you wouldn't have one. In my PA locality, we still have to file a local return so you would have one here. I am surprised that they would want you to file an amendment though and not just respond to a notice with explanation/proof of the tax paid.
