OK ... step 1 ... talk to the employer to stop the VT withholding since you live & work in NY... and see if they will withhold NY taxes instead.
step 2 ... in the MY INFO section you will only enter that you live & work in NY
step 3 ... in the STATE tab you will file a resident NY return and a NON resident VT return and allocate nothing to VT so you get all the withholding back.
