This one was tough to find. I had a similar situation and listed the steps below.
From a screen that read: "You Just Finished Your New York Return":
-Under "Credits & Other Taxes" section there's an option to click "Credits and other taxes"
It will indicate "Take a look at New York credits and taxes" at the top
- Look under "Other Tax Credits" Section
- Choose "Other Less Common Credits"
-"Uncommon Credits" header will appear
- click check box for "Claim for Pass-Through Entity Tax Credit (IT-653)"
