Thank you for your answer.
I followed your steps exactly. However, the numbers all check out
Income Taxed by NJ matches W2
Income Tax paid by me also matches W2
Tax Computed on Your New Jersey Return matches what TurboTax calculated in Tax Summary for NJ (Total Tax)
when I go for Review smart check still gives me the same error: IT-112-R (NJ): Tax Amount - TP should not be greater than the tax imposed by the other state.
Your advise how to address this is highly appreciated. I made another submission: 1130970
Thank you
