@MaryK4 I retract the statement about 401k being added. When you had mentioned it was odd I went back and took a look at every paystub and noticed when I got paid my annual bonus, VA state taxes were withheld. When I divided the amount taken from VA from the bonus by .0575, I got the numbers to match up pretty closely +/- few $100. I guess my 401k contribution and bonus was similar. Is it normal for portions of my annual bonus to be paid out to VA and NYC?
Also when I get to the end of wrapping up NY state taxes, I get an error because it is saying that NYC Locality Box 18 is greater than NYS Allocated (Box 1 - VA Box16)? (T-360.1 TP: Line 1b is greater than the amount of Wage income allocated to New York State on IT-203. Edit amounts on the Part-Year Resident/Nonresident Allocation Worksheet or City Wage/Self-Employment Income Allocation Worksheet as needed.)
