Is my W-2 incorrect? Employer created a nexus in PA

Hello,

 

I used to live and work in New York.  The company I work for is a small startup with payroll handled by Trinet.  I moved to PA at the very end of 2020.  My company decided to create a nexus in PA so I could avoid NY taxes, and this was done at the end of January 2021 (after 2 payroll periods) and my work location was changed to PA.

 

To make things simple, let's say that my income is $120,000 or $10,000 per month.  My W-2 has NY and PA both at approximately $120,000.  Shouldn't NY be only $10,000 (1 month) and PA be about $110,000?

 

When I did my taxes (which I now think are incorrect), Turbotax was saying that my taxable income in both PA and NY was around $120,000.  I had to assign a % for NY (and I chose 8% for 1 month), and ended up owing money to NY (even though NY taxes were withheld from my first 2 paychecks in 2021), but I believe the issue is that my W-2 is incorrect.

 

Can someone help to confirm this?

 

Thank you.

Cindy