Unfortunately, there would be no way for me to know. Pay stubs are useless as there are pay periods where part of the pay period is in one state and part in the other. It seems that it is only New York state that chooses to not break this down on the W2, but requires that breakdown in order to file a tax return ... how stupid is that. I'm not quite sure why the Vermont-labeled W2 doesn't have the Vermont income. Given that the W2 is from a large corporation, there is nobody to ask.
