@SundayInSalem said "The confusion apparently stems from johnhou92's employer withholding New York state income tax while also providing an outside office, which appears to be a contradiction".
I don't think there's any confusion. The WeWork space, alone, does not satisfy the convenience of the employer test. Based on info provided, @johnhou92 is working in TX, for his own convenience, and his employer is correctly withholding NY tax.
