Now it makes sense why you are unable to duplicate this, you are using a "professional tax program". For those reading this in the future, I was able to duplicate this programming error and reached out to TurboTax. The employee stated it is a well-known issue they are having and will walk you through editing your return on the final screen. They also agreed that in previous years it would immediately ask you for the IP PIN right after it asked you if you had one.
