Tax Return Rejected

So I got the dreaded 'IND-031-04 - The primary taxpayer's AGI or Self-select PIN from last year does not match IRS records'.  I have filed my previous 5+ years returns by mail so I haven't used a 'PIN'.  I submitted the returns twice and got the same rejection twice.  I have no issue filing by mail, but was hoping to do it electronically this year. I have verified that my AGI is correct from 2019, so I think the PIN is the issue. Any advice?