Extra W2 Over Reports Income

The company I worked for sent me two W2’s. I had an actual income of $36,500 that is on one W2. . The other W2 is for $19,100, money that I was not paid. I added all my paystubs, my total income was $36,500. Employer ID #’s are the same on both. Ive asked for a correction, the company tells me I need to just file the correct one, and forgot about the other $19,100 income they reported for me. They paid federal, soc sec, & medicare taxes on both the W2s. What should I do now??