Thanks @MinhT1
Two quick follow-up questions:
1) After doing this, TurboTax still warns me that I have over-contributed to my 401k. Do I just ignore this warning?
2) In the IRS 2022 instructions for 1099Rs (Pg. 17), it says that "that the earnings are taxable in the year in which the contributions were made", so wouldn't this mean that I would need to pay taxes on the earnings in 2021 since that's the year my contributions were made?
