Get your taxes done using TurboTax

The dollar value of the dividend does not change - it is fixed

Number of shares * share price = dollar value of dividend reinvestment

Since the number of shares is now 4x and the dollar value can not change, share price is divided by 4

Careful though, if there were dividend reinvestments after the first stock split , then multiply shares by 2 and divide share price by 2

Make sense?