@Norm85 I may have figured it out. So I viewed my NY state return to take a look at it and found that putting 10,200 for both was incorrect. This added an additional 10,200 to my NY taxable income. When I looked at my NY W-2 I now had my NY taxable income, Unemployment from NY, and now an additional 10,200.
So I went back and decided to put 0 in for NY for whichever question corresponded with the negative federal amount -10,200. I kept the 10,200 for whichever question had the positive 10,200. I then saved the new entry for my NY W-2 and went back to take a look at it now that it was updated. The NY W-2 now had only my NY taxable income and my NY unemployment. The additional 10,200 was no longer there and now said 0. This added value (which is now 0) was also right next the -10,200 on the federal side which I read as...Federal was forgiving -10,200 and NY was forgiving 0. Which I believe is the answer we're looking for...hopefully.
Haven't been able to submit my taxes yet because IRS is rejecting my return because of my previous year's AGI. Gonna try and just set my AGI to 0 and resubmit this weekend but that's a whole different issue. Good luck.
