Added a 1099-DIV and my refund went down three times as much

I added a 1099-DIV with Total ordinary dividends (Box 1a) of $64.12, and the result was that my tax refund decreased by $201.00. In other words, it seems that I'm paying $201.00 to the IRS for $64.12 in dividends. Could that be right?
I can add further information here, if there is not enough to answer my question.