Hello @DawnC,
So I only have 1 W-2. The Hours are given to me on a separate paycheck but end up going toward my total earnings. What I think might be happening is since these paychecks are given out to me as a regular 2 week pay cycle, but are around $300-$400 dollars, they are taxed in a lower bracket and not enough is taken out. Then at tax time, all the wages are included I was not taxed enough and end up owing. This is what I presented to my employer and asked if they could include everything on the same paystub but they said they could not.
Does this make sense?
