Actually, I solved my problem with importing from Fidelity into TurboTax.
As it turns out, TurboTax has problems with long passwords. My Fidelity password was 25 characters long. I changed it temporarily to 8 characters, and I was able to login to Fidelity from TurboTax and successfully imported my tax data. I then changed my Fidelity password to 20 characters (for security), since Fidelity now has a 20 character password limit.
