Got a hold of their support today. Talked to Princess, (super helpful btw) but you may not like the solution.
The solution ended up being that we had to delete the tax return and start over. By clicking Tax Tools/Tools options on the left side of the screen, then scroll down to Start Over, and re enter everything. When I did that, everything worked fine. The theory is that from the time I created Schedule E to when I went to file, TurboTax changed the form so that my version was no longer compatible. Starting over was the only fix for me. Though I was still able to import everything like I did previously.
