Appreciate your help, here is the rejection info "IND-512-01 - Each Dependent's SSN (or Qualifying Child Identifying Number on Form 1040SS(PR)) on this return must not match the Spouse SSN on another return." And it is true he did put her name and SSN on his return but that was because turbotax required it as he filled out the return. And he selected "Married Filing Separately" and he checked the box for "Someone else can claim your spouse as a dependent".
