It looks like you are asking from Online TurboTax, which is good for only one Federal return per account per year. Hopefully you didn't prepare 2 online returns in the same account! If so, the second one would overwrite the first.
What do you mean by "paid for five?"
Are you using desktop software (CD/download)? If so you can prepare unlimited number of returns with 5 free Federal efiles. There is a 24.99 fee to efile each state return, except no fee for New York state, and no fee to print and mail a state return.
So please explain your situation more. Most importantly, what product are you using---Online TurboTax (web browser version) or the desktop software (CD/download)?
