Thanks for providing the details. I did a test tax return with your numbers, and I did not have the problem, so it's not clear what's happening.
Please try something for me, on a hunch. The $258.53 in box 4 is actually 1 cent too high. It should be $258.52. Please try changing it to $258.52 and see if that makes the problem go away. I know TurboTax told you it was $82.27 too high, but just try what I'm suggesting as an experiment. I can't test it, because I didn't get the problem with $258.53. If making it 1 cent less works, you can file that way. The IRS doesn't care about a 1 cent difference.
Please post back and let us know what happens, either way. We've had a few reports of similar problems, and we're trying to pin down what's going on. We might have to ask you for more information to help figure out the problem.
