I have a similar problem. Turbotax says that my entire HSA contribution of $2400 is taxable (plus penalty) because I "said" that someone else was going to claim me as a dependent. However, I didn't say that in the section on basic info. I said that someone "could" claim me, but they were "not going" to claim me. No matter what I do, Turbotax says the "are" going to claim me, therefore the HSA contribution is taxable. I tried TaxSlayer, and they have it correct. I always used Turbotax because I thought they would be more accurate, but not this time.
