I would not file using either one of the W-2s you received. I would contact your former employer to get yet another corrected W-2, one that is actually correct. If you can't get this resolved by April 18, then I recommend you file and extension and file when you have the correct W-2. For information on filing an Automatic Extension of Time to File using TurboTax see the following FAQ: https://ttlc.intuit.com/replies/3301811
