I can't tell if you are saying that you are getting the correct answer on your income tax return, or not; it's just not clear.
BUT, if you are seeing a page titled "Your Employer Stock Plan Results" then it's clear that at some point you selected the SECOND option on the page that you get to when you click "Add More Details", that is, the option that reads "This sale may require special handling" because that's the ONLY WAY that page will ever come up.
If you've go the correct answer on your income tax return, great. You certainly can go the second route and get the correct answer. If you're not getting the correct answer then DELETE THE TRADE, don't attempt to just modify it, and try again following the above instructions.
