IND-032-04 - 'SpousePriorYearPIN' or 'SpousePriorYearAGIAmt'

I have tried to e-file my 2024 federal tax return 3 times, and I keep getting this error - "IND-032-04 - 'SpousePriorYearPIN' or 'SpousePriorYearAGIAmt'"

Last year I did not use TurboTax to file my return but I do have a copy of the 2023 return.  I used the AGI on line 11 from the 2023 return.  I also downloaded Tax Return transcripts from the IRS website for both myself and my wife (we filed "married filing jointly" in 2023 and 2024). The AGI on the 2023 return matches the AGI on the tax return transcripts I downloaded from the IRS.  Why does it keep getting rejected?   I don't want to paper file due to the long processing times the IRS has for paper filings.