Tax Extension Disaster Area

I am in FL, a disaster area per the IRS for Milton. 

My understanding is that there was an automatic extension to May 1, 2025 for federal returns. 

I thought I would be able to gather all info by then but I need additional time, I am now past the 15th of April, but would like to file an extension. 

Can I still do so? Using Form 4868, I tried with Turbotax but could not. Can I paper file or use freefilefillableforms 

Thank you