My personal tax return extension was rejected after midnight last night. The email from turbotax says this: What do I do?

I made a payment to the IRS for anticipated taxes and filed an extension for personal taxes at 9 pm my time yesterday (4/15/25). I received an email at 1 am from turbotax after I filed my extensions but I was asleep: R0000-902-01 - Taxpayer TIN in the Return Header must not be the same as a TIN of a previously accepted electronic return for the return type and tax period indicated in the tax return. In most cases, you just need to submit a new extension application before the filing deadline. I don't know why the TIN is wrong or what to do to fix it. I had filed my business taxes prior under the same turbotax account, is that why? Does this mean I will be penalized for not filing the extension.