pk
Level 15
Level 15

Get your taxes done using TurboTax

@Juancar , while I understand the underlying logic  behind requiring recognition  of "constructive receipt " for domestic  entities -- i.e.  you recognize the interest earnings   ( quarterly or whatever the contract calls out  as  "update/ increase period " ) even though you have no right to it without breaking the contract and therefore paying a penalty, my struggle is with the  undue & associated  penalty  that you incur because of foreign tax ---  e.g.  say the interest  at  4% annual , is  deposited/ recorded  quarterly.  Thus you  using the  "constructive receipt " recognize the  gain and are taxed  thereon.  But the foreign govt does not follow the same rule and recognizes the gain only once the three year term is complete.  So you then have  US taxes  on an yearly basis  but with no  Foreign tax credit . Then at the end of the three years you have a large Foreign tax  ,  but very little  US tax   ( because  most of the interest earnings have already been taxed by the US already ).  This means your foreign tax credit is pretty small -- credit is the lesser of  Foreign taxes paid  and US tax on the same income.

IMHO , one should ignore  the crediting of the interest till it is actually available and therefore the US  tax is on the same income as the foreign  taxed income.

I have no statute to support my position and have no case law to back it up.  But it seems logical

 

pk