I reentered all of the same information as a new 1099-R without a problem. The only thing that I can think of is that I MAY HAVE called the initial 1099-R a Replacement 1099-R because I was unsure of it's designation since this 1099-R wasn't automatically uploaded like all of my other 1099-R's were and I had to input the information myself. TurboTax never gave me the option to say it wasn't a replacement no matter how many times I hit "Back!"
