W2 import incorrect for 2023. Now got a CP2000 because I missed it.

I've used Turbo Tax for years and never had a problem with the W2 import feature.

 

For the 2023 tax year, I imported a W2 from an employer. The numbers seemed correct. I submitted and filed and paid taxes.

 

Yesterday I got a CP2000 from the IRS stating I did not report income from that employer. I dug up the suspect W2. The one imported from Turbotax has a close amount, but not the correct one. The IRS says I owe them 5k for not reporting this W2 correctly.

 

Where did turbotax import this w2 from? Why isn't it correct? I can't afford a massive tax bill because turbotax hallucinated a w2. I feel so stupid for not double checking. This is awful and I just want to talk to a real person and the phone tree is a nightmare.