runnerdude
Returning Member

do i HAVE to use any of my state CLC if there is no benefit to me ?

hi ... i'll use round numbers to make things easy ...

 

i entered 2024 with a CLC of $700 on my federal return ...

i had a long-term capital gain of $300 in 2024 ...

tax software applied my $700 CLC to my $300 long-term gain and

i ended up with a $400 loss for 2024 and no CLC for 2025 ... makes sense

 

on my state return (california) i entered 2024 with a CLC of $1000 ...

tax software applied my $1000 CLC to my $300 gain and i ended

up with ZERO gain for 2024 and a $700 state CLC for 2025 ...

 

here's the rub ... i wasted $300 of my california CLC because i didn't owe

any taxes (either with or without the capital gain) ... so why does the

tax software force you to use a portion of your CLC when doing so results

in NO benefit to the taxpayer ...

 

i feel like i justed wasted $300 of my CLC for nothing ...

 

thanks !