So I was finally able to resolve this issue. I downloaded and installed H&R Block Premium. Got to the eTrade 1099 OFX import section and it worked flawlessly. Sorry TurboTax. Been using your product for decades now and this is the first time it failed for me. Was not willing to wait around for a fix that may not come. For those are curious, the H&R software works almost identical to TurboTax so really no learning curve required.
