Even if there are two EIN numbers, combine the two W2's and report the HSA contribution in Box 12 on the W2 that reports your disability pay.
Thanks DaveF1006. Unfortunately both W2s already have entries on line 12a. On the main W2 it is category C- imputed income of Group Term Insurance. The other W2 as I mentioned is item W- employer contribution to my HSA.
FWIW, line 12b is already taken on the first W2, but both W2s have line 12c blank and so I suppose I could use that. But this whole thing just doesn't sound right. Hate to say it but sounds like another Print and Mail year.
