I finally got it to work after trying everything else, but first had to clear my return and start over (not optimal but worth it to get the totals to show up). As soon as I re-entered my first W2 I clicked on Federal Return and continued past all of the prompts asking me to fix things and the running total finally showed up on top! Important to note that you click on the Federal Review button and not the Review button under State Taxes. So far it's staying on there for me as I go back and complete the rest of my return.
