I had the same NYS 2024 estimated tax filing problem with TT Desktop Premier. I called Support, they opened an Investigation, and TT has now (3/14/25) released an update to "resolve" the problem. The update now says only the first of the 2024 NYS estimated tax payments can be filed electronically, and requires you to delete the other three from the form after you repeat the "review" step of your NYS return to be filed electronically. I did this and it allowed the 2023 return and the first 2024 estimate to be transmitted with no error messages.
