Get your taxes done using TurboTax

We have two W-2's:

W-2 #1 income is 353k - over the 200k and additional medicare was taken out

W-2 #2 income is 133k - under the 200k limit 

 

So now in the worksheet, since the limit is $250k I have to pay another $748 additional medicare even though W-2 never met the threshold (133k-50k * .9%). Shouldn't W-2 #2 be excluded since it didn't meet the threshhold?