I'm having the exact same problem. And I've done this successfully in years past, so I know it's not me. I'm following the instructions as advised, but it's still showing up taxable. I was able to get one to register correctly, but then entering the second one (my husband's) messed it all up and it's showing both as taxable, when they shouldn't be. Please let me know if you figure it out! I've tried erasing it all and reentering (both the nondeductible part and the conversion part) many times without success.
