drives2fast
Returning Member

Get your taxes done using TurboTax

Both pensions were nearly the exact amount.

I tested it by performing our taxes as if there was only one pension received and comparing the results.

If I entered only her pension (against her name), no other changes to the tax return, I observed the tax return being reduced by $x.  If I added $x to what she already paid federal taxes on for the year against her pension, it came out to a total of 37% fed taxes.  When I performed the same test with my pension (same dollar figure, but under my name, employed, but not contributing to the pension) it resulted in a calculated 27% fed tax rate. The only difference is that I am employed and she is not.

I understand how having them combined can potentially introduce other changes.  That's why I tested them individually.  And when I combine them together, the taxed amount and final tax return is the same if I were to add the individual test runs together.

I just found this interesting and a bit confusing.