Changing my W-4

This past year my wife and I both took new jobs and moved states. Throughout that process I must have filed my W-4 with my new company differently than my past employer, because this year I owed quite a bit and I had become accustomed to getting a refund rather than owing. 

 

My question is simple - what do I need to put on my W-4 so that I do not owe again next year?